Ways To Help Resolve A Shareholder Dispute

Paddle & Cocks LLP Solicitors • 28 March 2023

Shareholder disputes can be a significant concern for any company. Disputes can arise for many reasons, including disagreements over the direction of the company, management decisions, or dividend payments. Under English law, shareholders have legal rights and protections, including the right to take action against other shareholders in cases of unfair prejudice or even cause the company to take the action, know as a derivative claim. This blog post will explore the concept of unfair prejudice under the Companies Act and the legal remedies available to shareholders who require legal services.


Unfair Prejudice under the Companies Act


Section 994 of the UK Companies Act 2006 provides for the concept of unfair prejudice. Unfair prejudice occurs when the company's affairs are being conducted in a manner that is unfairly prejudicial to the interests of one or more shareholders, usually the minority shareholders but it can also arise where the shareholders are 50:50. This can include actions taken by the company or by other shareholders.


Examples of actions that may constitute unfair prejudice include:


  • Diverting company assets for personal gain
  • Excluding shareholders from decision-making processes
  • Diluting the value of a shareholder's shares
  • Failing to pay dividends to shareholders when appropriate


Legal Remedies for Shareholders


If a shareholder believes that they have been subject to unfair prejudice, they may instigate Court proceedings by issuing an unfair prejudice petition pursuant to s994 of the CA 2006. The following remedies are available in successful actions:


  1. Shareholders may apply to the court for an order to bring an end to the unfair prejudice.
  2. Shareholders may also seek an order for the company to purchase their shares at a fair value or the majority shareholders to buy out the minority shareholders who have suffered the unfair prejudice, for fair value.
  3. Shareholders may seek damages or compensation for any loss suffered as a result of the unfair prejudice.


In considering whether to make an order for relief, the court has a wide discretion and will consider the following factors:


  • The nature of the conduct complained of
  • The effect of that conduct on the company and its shareholders
  • The effect of the conduct on the complaining shareholder
  • The extent to which the conduct was consistent with the company's constitution and its principles of governance


It is important to note that shareholder disputes can be costly and time-consuming, and it is often in the best interests of all parties to seek alternative methods of dispute resolution, such as mediation or arbitration. These methods can be less expensive and less time-consuming than going to court, and they can help to preserve the relationships between the parties involved.


By A. E. Verona Cocks, partner & Sam Till, work experience student.


Get in Contact

If you have a shareholders dispute and would like further advice please contact Verona Cocks either by email verona.cocks@paddleandcocks.co.uk or on 01872 672072 or 0203 7456535


The information in this blog is intended to be general information about English law only and not comprehensive. It is not to be relied on as legal advice nor as an alternative to taking professional advice relating to specific circumstances.

by Harjit Gill 11 December 2024
How the New Employment Rights Bill will Strengthen the Employees Employment Protections. By Harjit Gill The upcoming Employment Rights Bill proposes significant changes to the protections employees enjoy in the workplace. If the individual is an employee, understanding how this new Bill will affect an employee’s rights is essential. This article focuses on the key changes relating to unfair dismissal. Key Changes in the New Bill Day-One Protection Against Unfair Dismissal Under the current rules, employees must work for an employer for two years before they can claim unfair dismissal, unless it relates to pregnancy, whistleblowing or trade union membership. This means that if the employer dismisses the employee in the first two years, the employee will have limited recourse to challenge that decision. The two-year qualifying period for unfair dismissal claims will be abolished, and the employee will have the right to challenge an unfair dismissal from the first day of their employment. This change will provide the employee with greater job security and protection, ensuring that employers cannot dismiss the employee arbitrarily during their early employment. New Statutory Probation Period Along with the introduction of day-one protection, the Bill proposes a statutory probationary period of nine months. During this probationary period, employers will have to follow a simplified process for dismissal if they feel that the employee is not the right fit for the role. The government are yet to detail what this process involves but it will definitely be subject to the rules of fairness. After the nine-month probationary period, full protections against unfair dismissal will apply and employers will be required to follow a more rigorous and fair process to dismiss their employees. Right to Written Reasons for Dismissal Currently, the employee must have worked for an employer for two years to request written reasons for the employee’s dismissal. Under the new Bill, this will change. The employee will be able to request written reasons for your dismissal after the nine-month probation period. This ensures that if the employee is dismissed after this period, the employer must provide a clear and written explanation, giving the employee transparency and the ability to assess whether the dismissal was fair. Impact on Your Job Security These changes will significantly improve the employee’s job security, particularly in the early months of employment. Previously, many employees had limited rights during their first two years on the job. Employers could dismiss employees without the need to provide reasons or follow formal procedures unless the employee’s dismissal fell under “automatically unfair” reasons like discrimination or whistleblowing. With day-one protection, employees will have immediate access to employment rights that ensure their employer must act fairly if they choose to dismiss the employee. This change will particularly benefit the 9 million workers in the UK who have been with their employer for less than two years. While these changes offer employees stronger protections, it’s important to understand that employers will still have flexibility and can insert a longer probationary period than what is proposed in the employees’ contract, especially for more complex roles. However, once the statutory nine-month probationary period is complete, the employee will be fully protected by unfair dismissal laws. This means that any dismissal must follow standard procedures and be based on legitimate reasons, such as performance issues or misconduct. When Will These Changes Happen? The reforms in the Employment Rights Bill are expected to take effect no sooner than autumn 2026. This gives employees time to prepare for these changes, while also giving employers time to adjust their policies. However, it’s essential to be aware of these changes now, so employees understand the rights they will have when the Bill becomes law. Conclusion The Employment Rights Bill is set to transform the protections employees enjoy, particularly regarding unfair dismissal. From day-one protection to the introduction of a statutory probation period, their rights as an employee will be strengthened, offering greater security, in the employees first year on the job, helping to create a fairer and more balanced workplace for all. If you require any further information or legal advice on any of the points raised, please contact Harjit Gill on harjit.gill@paddleandcocks.co.uk or telephone 0333 344 9429 quoting HG. *The above highlights some of the changes the Bill is intended to bring about and is not intended to provide legal advice which should be relied on.
by Justine Benbough 4 December 2024
Renters’ Rights Bill 2024 – A brief overview of proposed changes By Justine Benbough What is it? Proposes changes to the UK rental market Likely to come into force Spring 2025 Current ASTs likely to become periodic assured tenancies overnight Key Changes Abolishes fixed term assured shorthold tenancy Replaces this with a periodic assured tenancy Abolishes non fault evictions (the old Section 21 procedure) Requires landlords to prove grounds for eviction under Section 8 Section 8 Grounds for Possession Makes changes to existing grounds Introduces new grounds Introduces longer notice periods No longer accelerated ‘paper’ procedure In person possession hearings only Rent Arrears (Ground 8) Remains a mandatory ground but now tenants must be at least 3 months (13 weeks) in arrears (no longer 2 months/8 weeks) Landlord to give 4 weeks’ notice (no longer 14 days) Student Accommodation Applies to full time students living in an HMO Possession can be obtained under Ground 4A Require landlords to serve prior notice of intention to relet to students at start of new academic year Section 8 notice to end tenancy must give 4 months’ notice to expire within the holiday period (1st June and 30th September) Pets & Discrimination Cannot be a barrier to renting Landlord cannot unreasonably refuse Rent Reform Introduces a bar on rent bidding Rent review clauses no longer apply Introduces rent increase mechanism and procedure for challenging Landlords’ Duties To provide tenants with written statement of terms and certain information Non-compliance with landlord’s duties and rules on service of notices can lead to financial penalties Expands Awaab’s Law to private sector Local Authority Powers Increased by enforcing civil penalties for landlord’s failing to comply with the regulations Landlord Redress Scheme Landlord required to register with scheme Deals with tenant complaints If you require any further information or legal advice on any of the points raised, please contact Justine Benbough on justine.benbough @paddleandcocks.co.uk or telephone 0333 344 9429 quoting JEB. *The above highlights some the changes the Bill is intended to bring about in bullet point form only and is not intended to provide legal advice which should be relied on
by Paddle & Cocks LLP Solicitors 18 April 2023
The Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS) is an initiative designed to stimulate economic growth and innovation by encouraging investment in small, early-stage companies.
A commercial lawyer with a client
by Paddle & Cocks LLP Solicitors 28 March 2023
In the following article, we’ll outline the range of benefits of commercial lawyers and explain why they’re essential for your small business.
Business units
by Paddle & Cocks Ltd 28 February 2023
Paddle & Cocks is frequently contacted by people who are confused about the process of selling a business. Here is more information about the process.
City scene
by Paddle & Cocks Ltd 1 February 2023
Corporate law is often a nuanced and challenging subject to understand. So check out this blog and we’ll sum up commercial dispute resolution simply.
Group of shareholders
by Paddle & Cocks Ltd 1 February 2023
Ensuring that your business has a strong shareholders’ agreement in place is the key to corporate operations running smoothly in the long term.
law firm, solicitors, employment law, settlement agreements
9 January 2023
If you have been given a settlement agreement this allow Paddle & Cocks LLP to take you through the process and answer common questions.
Legal 500 accreditation
by Paddle & Cocks LLP Solicitors 5 January 2023
Settlement agreements may be a complex subject for those with a limited understanding of employment law. Allow us to take you through common queries.
Contract written on paper
by Paddle & Cocks LLP Solicitors 5 January 2023
Corporate and commercial law are slightly separate legal fields. Read to find out the differences between them and how this can affect your legal needs.
Share by: